Saturday, March 21, 2015

Nandanaar - A more probable Realistic View


This is in response to the numerous comments on Nandanaar movie in Youtube:

The Nandanar story is shredded with mostly nonsensical and emotional stuff forgetting the socioeconomic structure of the period in South India, especially Tamilnadu.

The main fault is in projecting the socioeconomic structure with what was found in the early 20th century by people born at that time - whether Brahmins or other leaders, to a time 1000 years back! So with Gopalakrishnan who projected a very misconceived notion and the communists of that period who used it for their own political gains.

Nandanar, going by literature mentioning's, lived around 8th century or 9th century; it was beginning of the golden period of Chola's (probably just before the veeranam lake dug by Rajaditya in the name of his father Paranthaka to hold part of the Cauvery's floods through Kollidam for later use in irrigation).  Saivism is deep rooted in the Tamil community and had nothing to do with Vedic stuff. In fact Brahmanism itself was struggling to take root at that time - the kings and other chieftains while respecting Brahmanism were not outrageously supportive of them. The later fight at Chidambaram by Raja Raja to recover the holy writings of many older saints is a testimony of the amount of hold that Brahmins had at that time.

Most stories of Nandhanar depict that there were only two castes - Bharamins and pariahs!!! what about all the intermediate castes? In those days probably the Tamil community went by the trade rather then caste - the castes rigidified as time progressed in most of south India.

There were artisans, gold smiths, tanners, blacksmiths, velalars (agriculturist), warriors and also brahmins to just name a few. It is not correct that brahmins held land – definitely not at that time and often it is the other way around. They were respected mostly for their astronomical observations to provide the right time of sowing, etc. and also their ability to understand and translate any knowledge that came in from the north (like the never fading paints, some metallurgy, etc.). They were usually given some part of temple land in keeping up the maintenance of the temple (many of the bronze plates depict this) and exempted from taxation.

By all accounts, it seems that Nandanar was not only involved in drum making (so having a good knowledge of music) but also a village head (Nattamai). He couldn't have dug a tank without the strength of 100s of laborers who can work for him - saying god built it for him is escapism from factual thinking. Refusal to temple entry itself is questionable as dasi's, kings, village heads and most are of non-brahmin community at that time and they were present in every function at the temple. Refusal to temple entry came later and probably around 17th or 18th century. Even at Kulothunga's time (probably the last of the great kings of the chola's golden time) around 14-15th century this act was not prevalent.

The Nandanar story might have been that he questioned the brahminic lore and pointed out that Shiva was not their god and they had no say in saivism. Probably he was burnt alive in Chidambaram by the brahmins there (who were also trained warriors as found in later times in Kerala). But the later people included him in the nayanar's list - but note that none of his works survive, like many other nayanar and these were the systematic works of bhramins and others who wanted to absorb and rebuild saivism to augment the brahminic cult.

So, better to think rationally and with all the available facts and pointers at hand rather than considering wishful thinking as facts.

And anyway caste or creed or birth has nothing to do with GOD.

Monday, March 10, 2014

Inheritance Tax

It had been the problem of John in his young age as he was never accepted in his circle. While there were a lots to hang out with him there was none who had been close and accepting what he was in reality. The problem – simple, his parents were very rich and he was the only child. 

It had been the exact opposite for Smith. He was born to poor parents and none listened to him and took him as an equal or someone of importance. While the government facilitated his studies – that too with a grudge, he doesn’t have even small change to spend and be in an acceptance circle.

The question now is that both of them are from the same society and it is the churning of the society that had made one father successful and another not. Now those successful write books on top of the graves of thousand they buried in becoming successful and make more success. The society as such never looks at those buried. While being successful and fulfilling one's needs seems to be okay, going beyond and amassing wealth for their children and children’s children and so on (no end and no limits) looks rather shaky. 

Especially when each cent we make, we are indirectly making someone poorer by more than a cent – as our additional cent has come through brokers, mediators and hoarders on top of the unending chain of commission makers more fancifully known as facilitators, who take a lion’s share, sometimes several times the original cent. Of course, you need these gimmicks to feed the ever growing population and to make them do something useful, so that someone else might save time and do something more meaningful and useful. But after a good head start, it has gone wayward and is now becoming the main stay with the original contributors pushed to the back. Not only the thinkers and inventors but also farmers and productive personnel (do note that I do not use the word worker as it sums up all that is said above and has a negative connotation) has been pushed to the back stage. When we think of 'Gates' opening and 'Jobs' flowing, we do not even bother to know about the people who made it possible. Like - just pay them some titbits, they are there to make us rich.

So, in top of all these, should we amass wealth for our off-springs and their generations? If you think it in a particular way, this might prove to be the root cause of all the social evil and the disregard to the ecosystem, as each literally rapes it to amass more, as there are many more generations to come (at least in their wishful thinking). Otherwise why some, say, Indians horde their money in Swiss banks – enough to contribute and sustain 10% of the Swiss economy?

What is the solution? Should the wealth accumulated by an individual after his time go to the government? Looks too socialistic to be of practical value – none of the governments in the world running along these lines, as they are still run by human and not gods, seems good enough to do that. Is there an alternative - For John to feel justified of his wealth from his family and Smith to get some money too from a mediator like the government? Well, why not have an inheritance tax? You see this topic of taxing inheritance seems to have been meticulously avoided in all cultures and over the last few thousand year and in all parts of the world. Some do it purposefully and for some, in the other extreme, there was no need, as all property belonged to the clan. Or in those times, power rather than wealth defined the social status or hierarchical position within the society. The feudal system slowly emerged into a system that preservers the position and wealth of the genetic line even if the individuals or not capable to be of service to the social set up as their elders had been.

What if there is an inheritance tax of say 33.33% or 1/3 of the wealth paid to the government coffers (I wonder at the name!). It can use such funds to provide monetary benefits to those whose parents are poor – which was caused both by their own inefficiency and also because somebody got wealthy through making them poor (Think of a society as a closed system – that will give an understanding of the parity in wealth more clearly). Also many who run the government and their minions can make a lot of money through underhand dealings and kickbacks – but still they too must leave 1/3 behind to society on their demise. What if the wealth is in the form of an estate with no liquid money to pay of the 1/3rd to tax? Well, there will be so many intermediaries like banks, financial “institutions” and other NGOs who might strike a bargain. Or the government, like doing our current tax games to keep the cross-section of people happy and content might have a poll promise to exclude certain inheritance like living house, etc., from inheritance tax. The possibilities are endless, for making additional livelihood in such a new game. Why not homo-sapiens consider it?